Reviews in Whitby

This was the best meal of the week. I had the Magpie medley and it was delicious. Every item was perfectly cooked and correctly seasoned. The staff were friendly and attentive. The rest of my group equally enjoyed their meals of cod and chips x2, lasagne and beef burger. A lovely evening, thank you.

Superb fish and chip meal at Magpie Cafe with my wife and Dad, who recommended we go there during our visit. Great staff too, definitely on our list when we return.

Amazing food, friendly staff and good atmosphere

Had a really lovely Meal at the Magpie service was excellent and staff friendly certainly go back.

Brilliant food (the fishpie was amazing) and the staff are so lovely ! Will definitely be coming back and recommending it.

Great service and the food was really lovely!!

Absolutely fantastic food. Would definitely come back and would recommend

Beautiful meal. Morning ch better being able to book so no queueing on the stairs.

The dining experience at the Magpie is excellent because not only is the food, service and atmosphere is consistently good it is also a restaurant that you can eat and never be short of menu options because they offer a wide array of choices all exceptionally well cooked. We have visited the Magpie many times and always been delighted with every aspect.

Have been going to the Magpie for over 25 years and this last experience was not one of the best. Service was slow. Ordered bread and butter which finally came (after having to ask again) when we had almost finished our meal. Haddock is normally lovely but this piece was lacking in meat and the batter was not the usual light crisp texture. Skate also was not the usual white flesh but grey. Scampi starter is normally nice large langoustine/prawn these had shrunk in size and the breadcrumb coating not as light. I appreciate covid is having an impact but kitchen needs to up its game or we will not be back

Had a really lovely Meal at the Magpie service was excellent and staff friendly certainly go back.

My daughter an I went yesterday and I remembered to book a table as its so popular! I've been before and it never disappoints! The food is beautifully cooked and presented, the best seafood for hundreds of miles! I wish this size would let me put on pics but sadly it doesn't. Anyway don't hesitate book and go! You won't regret it!

Visited 20 July. 3 of us had standard fish, chips mushy peas and tea. Absolutely gorgeous.

As a group of six, we went for an evening meal. We had a brilliant night, not only was the food amazing, the service was too. We had Tracey as our waitress, what an asset she is , great customer service, nothing too much trouble and a fantastic personality. Every dish was delicious , cooked to everyone’s individual preference. 5star across the board, we will definitely be back.

First time we have been here in many years, and the fish and chips did not disappoint. The service was great, friendly staff. Quality food all in all a lovely evening

We visited this lovely restaurant on a very busy Saturday evening in July. We had booked in advance and the table was ready upon arrival. The food was delicious - we had Grilled Plaice, Monk Fish, Salmon and Cod with chips of course! All the fish was flaky and tasty and well presented. The staff were very attentive and friendly. The only negative thing I have to say is that it was very hot in the restaurant. I had taken a hand held fan and had to use it regularly. It was the hottest weekend so it probably isn't usually that warm inside. Definitely recommend a visit to this restaurant.

Booked a month in advance to be sat at the back of the restaurant in the corner. Food was average & nowhere near as good as on our previous visit. Service was pleasant but seemed to be over busy.

We'd heard of the brilliant reputation of The Magpie and that it was very popular so we booked a few weeks in advance. I have to say that it didn't disappoint. Our meals were amazing! The food was excellent and the service was high quality. I would completely recommend spending some time here.